Orange County Theatre Reviews

The cast of South Coast Repertory's 2013 production of A CHRISTM

photo courtesy: South Coast Repertory

Written by Alina Mae Wilson 

What exactly makes a story and show stand the test of time? The obvious challenge in answering this question stems from the fact that each show is different and therefore entertains its audience in another way. In the case of Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol, the more arguable answer is the continued relevancy of the main character’s journey. South Coast Repertory’s newest presentation of this iconic tale lives up to theatergoers’ expectations in most ways, bringing the play to you with visual beauty and convincing acting.

Ebenezer Scrooge is a bitter old miser who harbors an aversion to anything resembling Christmas cheer. This includes smiling, using more coal when the room is freezing, and accepting invitations to dinner from your only known relative. Other characters assure the audience that this is not simply a result of the holiday; Scrooge is the epitome of stingy loneliness all year. The man neither gives nor receives happiness. The catalyst of his journey towards change begins with a visit from his now-deceased business party Jacob Marley’s ghost, who informs him of the coming of three Christmas Spirits, which will help him change his fate.

Everything regarding the appearance of this show is fantastic. The costumes are everything that might be desired, the lighting is dismal/uplifting in all of the right parts, and the special effects exceed expectations. Ebenezer Scrooge is described in the program as a “grasping, covetous old man,” and his role is played accordingly. The caustic tone used when he is bargaining the terms of his impoverished clerk’s one day per year shows a side of Scrooge that I have not seen in any other adaptation–he might be something of a sadist. His snide comments and withering stares indicate that he is not simply grouchy but is actively enjoying causing harm to someone weaker than himself.   In other versions, he is usually just in a bad mood.

One of the weaker acting aspects of the night was the moments of fear Ebenezer felt when meeting the ghosts. The emotions of fear didn’t come through, as did all the other emotions the actor displayed that night. 

For some strange reason, the director cut Tiny Tim’s beloved “God bless us, everyone.” Though I grew up with the show, I was never terribly attached to this line, so I wasn’t too upset.   But it made me wonder why–is it shying away from the original religious overtones of the work? If so, it seems strange to have a scene involving Scrooge on his knees praying to God.

Overall they delivered the story in its original format, with a beautifully direct hit on the target of humanity’s potential for love, kindness, and warmth.

8.5/10

Date & Location :

November 28th – December 27th

South Coast Repertory 

655 Town Center Drive, PO Box 2197, Costa Mesa

South Coast Repertory 

If you liked this article, subscribe with your email on the front page.

3 Responses to A Christmas Carol @ South Coast Repertory in Costa Mesa – Review

  1. Gary Severen says:

    i have been Scrooge for 20 years this year-that line is essential! We are just a community theatre, but I think we can hold our on against the big guys. In fact, popular demand has caused us to run extra shows after Christmas. I would like to personally invite you to my show at 2pm on Saturday! Please look at http://www.musicaltheatrevillage.net.
    Happy Holidays
    Ebeneezer